BACnet gets compared to a lot of other protocols on the market, including LonWorks, Modbus, and KNX. In this article, we break down the advantages and disadvantages of each protocol. Be sure to check out our articles on each of the protocols: LonWorks, Modbus, KNX, and a few reasons we think you should adopt BACnet. 

The question of “Which is better?” has served as a fundamental Rorschach test for the building automation industry for nearly 30 years. It’s a bit like asking “Which language is best?” The answer depended entirely on who you are talking to and what you were trying to say.

In 2025, the dust has largely settled. We aren’t just connecting boilers and chillers anymore; we are connecting buildings to the cloud, to AI, and to the electrical grid. To do that, devices need to speak a common language. And that language is largely BACnet (BACnet/IP if you want to be picky).

This article updates the classic comparison of the “Big Four”—BACnet, Modbus, LonWorks, and KNX—stripping away the academic jargon to explain how they actually fit into modern buildings and why one of them has emerged as the clear global winner.

For fun, I asked ChatGPT what it thought of each “language”, and here’s how it described it:

• BACnet is like English in the business world. It is the global standard for complex negotiations (building operations). It’s verbose, structured, and widely understood by almost everyone.
• Modbus is like Morse Code. It is ancient, incredibly simple, and works over almost any wire. It doesn’t have a large vocabulary, but it’s perfect for sending simple messages like “The tank is full.”
• KNX is like German. It is precise, robust, and dominant in Europe. It is excellent for handling many small, decentralized tasks (like lighting and blinds) efficiently.
• LonWorks is like Latin. It was once the language of the educated elite (engineers) and was structurally beautiful. But today, fewer people speak it fluently, and it requires specific “interpreters” (specialized chips and tools) to work.

For the most part, we agree. But let’s add a bit more context. Here’s a simple table outlining what these protocols best represent in 2025:

1. BACnet: The Global “De Facto” Standard

BACnet (Building Automation and Control Networks) is maintained by ASHRAE specifically for buildings. It isn’t just a way to move data; it’s a way to model a building.

How it Works

BACnet represents data as Objects. A temperature sensor isn’t just a number; it’s an “Analog Input Object” that has properties like its current value, its high limit, and its unit of measure (e.g., degrees Fahrenheit).   

It generally runs on two types of networks:

1. BACnet/IP: Runs over standard Ethernet cables and WiFi, just like your office laptop. This is fast and increasingly the standard for modern controllers.
2. BACnet MS/TP: Runs over twisted-pair copper wires (RS-485). You’ll find this in older buildings or cheaper equipment daisy-chained from room to room.

Why It’s Winning (The Market Leader)

BACnet currently holds approximately 60-77% of the global market share (90%+ in North America) for building automation. Why?   

• It’s Open: No single company owns it. You can buy a Johnson Controls chiller, a Siemens valve, and a Delta Controls thermostat, and they can all theoretically talk to each other without buying a license from a gatekeeper.
• Scalability: It works for a single room or a massive university campus.
• IT Friendly: Because standard BACnet/IP runs on standard IT networks, it’s easier for IT departments to manage than weird, proprietary wiring systems.

2. Modbus: The “Old Reliable”

Modbus is the grandfather of protocols, dating back to 1979. Despite its age, it is still used in almost every industrial setting.

How it Works

Modbus is a Master-Slave protocol (though now often called Client-Server). The “Master” shouts a request (“Device 1, give me the value in Register 4001”), and the “Slave” responds (“100”). That’s it. It doesn’t know what Register 4001 is—it could be temperature, pressure, or a fan speed. You need a separate “decoder ring” (a points list) to understand the data.

The Verdict

• Pros: It’s cheap, simple, and ubiquitous. If you buy a generator, a power meter, or a boiler, it probably speaks Modbus.
• Cons: It requires a lot of manual setup to map those registers to meaningful names. It also has zero security—anyone on the network can read or write commands.   

3. KNX: The King of Room Control

KNX is a powerhouse in Europe and is growing in the US for high-end residential and commercial lighting control.

How it Works

Unlike BACnet, which usually relies on a central controller to make big decisions, KNX is decentralized. If you press a KNX light switch, it talks directly to the light fixture. If the central computer dies, your lights still work. This makes it incredibly reliable.   

The Verdict

• Pros: It looks great. KNX manufacturers make beautiful keypads and interfaces. It’s also rock-solid reliable for lighting and blinds.
• Cons: It can be expensive to install and commission. In North America, it is often seen as a niche solution for luxury homes or specific room controls, rather than a whole-building HVAC backbone.   

4. LonWorks: The Fading Star

LonWorks (Local Operating Network) was BACnet’s biggest rival in the 90s and 2000s. It used a clever technology called “twisted pair free topology” that made wiring very forgiving.

How it Works

LonWorks historically relied on a specific computer chip (the Neuron chip) inside every device to handle communications. This guaranteed that devices played nicely together because they all used the exact same hardware logic.

The Verdict

In 2025, LonWorks is in a tough spot. The reliance on specific hardware became a bottleneck. Recently, major chip manufacturers (like Renesas) have exited the market or discontinued key components, forcing the ecosystem to scramble for software-based alternatives.   

Cons: It is becoming a “legacy” technology. Finding technicians who understand LNS databases and plugins is getting harder every year.

Pros: Great for difficult wiring situations (like power line communication).

TLDR: Whis is Better?

If you are updating a building or building a new one in 2025, here is the cheat sheet:

1. For the Core System (HVAC/BMS): Use BACnet/IP. It is the global standard, supported by everyone, and future-proofs your data for analytics.
2. For Energy Meters & Generators: You will likely be stuck with Modbus. That’s fine—just use a gateway to translate it into BACnet as soon as possible.
3. For Lighting & Room Control: KNX is a strong contender if you want reliability and aesthetics, but ensure it integrates back to your BACnet system.
4. For Legacy Retrofits: You might encounter LonWorks, but think twice before specifying it for a brand-new project unless you have a very specific wiring constraint.

In the end, BACnet has won the war for the “backbone” of the building. It provides the standardized data structure that modern AI and cloud tools need to actually make your building smart.

Want to know more? Check out our Ultimate BACnet FAQ.

How many issues will you solve today?

Sign Up For Free